Can I make an hourly employee exempt?

No. Exempt employees must be paid on a salary basis, meaning a fixed amount per week regardless of hours worked. Hourly employees by definition are paid based on hours worked. To make someone exempt, you would need to convert them to a salary that meets the FLSA threshold and confirm their duties meet one of the exemption tests.

What if an exempt employee works less than 40 hours?

You must still pay their full weekly salary. Deducting pay because an exempt employee worked 35 hours instead of 40 undermines the salary basis test and can jeopardize their exempt status. The only permissible deductions are for full-day absences for personal reasons or full-day absences due to sickness under a bona fide sick leave plan.

Do exempt employees need to track their hours?

The FLSA does not require employers to track hours for exempt employees. However, some states and some company policies require it for PTO accrual, project costing, or billing purposes. Even where not legally required, tracking exempt hours can provide useful data for workload analysis and staffing decisions.

What happens if I reclassify an exempt employee to non-exempt?

The employee becomes eligible for overtime pay going forward. You should communicate the change clearly, explain that their total compensation will likely stay similar (base salary plus occasional overtime may equal or exceed previous salary), and begin tracking their hours immediately. Most employees react positively when the change is framed as ensuring they are compensated for all hours worked.

Are there any employees who are always exempt regardless of salary?

Certain categories have special rules. Doctors, lawyers, and teachers can be exempt regardless of salary under the professional exemption. Outside sales employees (who work primarily away from the employer's place of business) are exempt regardless of salary. Computer employees can be paid hourly at $27.63 or more and still qualify for exemption. These are narrow exceptions.

Exempt vs. Non-Exempt: Overtime Rules Every Manager Should Know

The Three Tests for Exempt Status

Under the FLSA, an employee must pass all three tests to be classified as exempt from overtime requirements.

Test 1: Salary Basis. The employee must be paid a fixed salary that does not vary based on hours worked or quality of work. If you dock an exempt employee's pay because they left two hours early on Tuesday, you may have converted them to non-exempt status for that pay period.

Test 2: Salary Level. The employee must earn at least $684 per week ($35,568 annually) as of 2024. This is the federal minimum. Several states set higher thresholds. California's threshold for 2024 is $66,560 for employers with 26 or more employees. New York City's threshold is $62,400. Washington state's is $67,724.80.

Test 3: Duties. This is where most misclassification errors occur. The employee's primary duties must fit one of these categories:

Executive: Manages a department or subdivision, regularly directs the work of two or more employees, has authority to hire or fire (or recommendations carry weight).
Administrative: Performs office or non-manual work directly related to business operations, exercises discretion and independent judgment on significant matters.
Professional: Performs work requiring advanced knowledge in a field of science or learning, acquired through prolonged specialized study.

A shift supervisor at a manufacturing plant who spends 80% of their time operating machinery alongside their team is not performing executive duties, regardless of their title. A construction foreman who personally swings a hammer most of the day while occasionally assigning tasks is likely non-exempt.

Common Misclassification Scenarios in Hands-On Industries

Misclassification is especially common in construction, manufacturing, and transportation because the line between supervisor and worker is blurry in these industries.

The working foreman. A construction foreman who manages a crew of five but also performs manual labor alongside them for the majority of the day. If manual labor is their primary duty (more than 50% of their time), the executive exemption likely does not apply. They should be classified as non-exempt and receive overtime.

The office manager who also does payroll. An office manager at a small warehousing company who handles administrative tasks, answers phones, processes payroll, and manages the front desk. If this person does not exercise independent judgment on significant business matters, the administrative exemption does not apply. Processing payroll according to established procedures is not the same as exercising discretion.

The salaried driver. A transportation company pays a driver a fixed salary regardless of hours. Being salaried does not make them exempt. Driving does not meet the executive, administrative, or professional duties tests. This driver is entitled to overtime even though they receive a salary. The salary simply needs to be converted to an hourly rate for overtime calculation purposes.

The assistant manager. A staffing agency "assistant branch manager" who spends most of their time placing temporary workers, handling paperwork, and occasionally covering shifts at client sites. Without regular supervisory authority over two or more employees, the executive exemption fails.

In each case, the employer intended the classification to be correct. The problem is that the duties test is based on actual work performed, not the job description on file.

The Financial Cost of Getting It Wrong

Misclassification lawsuits under the FLSA are among the most common types of employment litigation, and the math works strongly in the employee's favor.

Individual claims: An employee misclassified as exempt who worked an average of 5 hours of overtime per week at an effective hourly rate of $25 is owed $18.75 per overtime hour (the unpaid 0.5x premium, since they already received straight-time pay). Over two years, that is approximately $9,750. If the violation is willful (three-year lookback), it is $14,625. Add liquidated damages (equal to back pay), and the individual liability reaches $19,500 to $29,250 before attorney fees.

Collective actions: The FLSA allows employees to file collective actions where all similarly situated employees can join. If 20 misclassified employees file together with the same facts, the per-employee math multiplies by 20. The average FLSA collective action settlement exceeds $6 million.

State law claims: Many states allow additional penalties and longer lookback periods. California's Private Attorney General Act (PAGA) allows penalties of $100 per employee per pay period for initial violations and $200 for subsequent violations, with no cap.

The cost of correctly classifying an employee as non-exempt and paying overtime when it occurs is almost always a fraction of the misclassification liability. For companies managing this manually, a time tracking system that automatically calculates overtime for all non-exempt employees prevents the calculation errors that compound into larger liability.

How to Audit Your Current Classifications

If you suspect your company may have misclassified employees, here is a practical audit process that does not require outside counsel for the initial assessment.

Step 1: Pull a list of all salaried employees. For each one, note their salary, job title, department, and who they report to.

Step 2: Apply the salary test. Any salaried employee earning below $35,568 annually (or your state's higher threshold) is automatically non-exempt regardless of duties. Flag these immediately.

Step 3: Review actual duties, not job descriptions. For each remaining salaried employee, ask their direct manager: what does this person actually do most of the day? Do they supervise two or more people? Do they have hiring or firing authority? Do they exercise independent judgment on business operations? Write down honest answers, not aspirational ones.

Step 4: Reclassify conservatively. For any position where the duties test is questionable, reclassify as non-exempt. The overtime cost is known and budgetable. The misclassification liability is not.

Step 5: Implement tracking for all non-exempt employees. Once classified correctly, non-exempt employees need accurate time records. The FLSA requires employers to maintain records of hours worked for all non-exempt employees. This is where automated time tracking becomes a compliance tool, not just a management tool. The Gap Assessment can help you quantify the compliance gap in your current tracking process.

How EasyClocking Supports Compliance

EasyClocking's platform tracks hours for all non-exempt employees with biometric verification, automatically calculates overtime based on federal and state rules, and maintains audit-ready records that satisfy FLSA recordkeeping requirements. The system distinguishes between regular and overtime hours in real time, giving managers visibility into labor costs before they become payroll surprises. For companies reclassifying employees after an internal audit, the transition is straightforward: add the employee to the system and their hours are tracked from day one.

Exempt vs. Non-Exempt: Overtime Rules Every Manager Should Know

What You Need to Know

Is your time tracking system fair to your team?

Frequently Asked Questions

Clocked

Not Ready for a Quote? Start Here.

The Three Tests for Exempt Status

Common Misclassification Scenarios in Hands-On Industries

The Financial Cost of Getting It Wrong

How to Audit Your Current Classifications

How EasyClocking Supports Compliance